Pattern selection for OPC (Optical Proximity Correction) model calibration is crucial for high-quality OPC results and low edge placement error (EPE) error in semiconductor fabrication. Pattern coverage check is also desired with the value to identify potential anomaly before mask tape out for monitoring and repair. This study evaluates pattern diversity based selection and pattern coverage check for Extreme Ultraviolet (EUV) C/H mask layers. Pattern diversity based selection has the advantage of incorporating information related to lithographic contrast and illumination effects, offering a more nuanced representation of patterns in a lithographic context. Using unsupervised machine learning, we analyze the lithographic pattern representations from sample designs and select out pattern representatives for OPC model. The study concludes pattern selection and coverage check can enhance model prediction performance for the OPC applications.
Calibration pattern coverage is critical for achieving a high quality, computational lithographic model. An optimized calibration pattern set carries sufficient physics for tuning model parameters and controlling pattern redundancy as well as saving metrology costs. In addition, as advanced technology nodes require tighter full chip specifications and full contour prediction accuracy, pattern selection needs accommodate these and consider contour fidelity EP (Edge Placement) gauges beyond conventional test pattern sets and cutline gauge scopes. Here we demonstrate an innovative pattern selection workflow to support this industry trend. 1) It is capable of processing a massive candidate pattern set at the full chip level. 2) It considers physical signals from all of the candidate pattern contours. 3) It implements our unsupervised machine learning technology to process the massive amount of physical signals. 4) It offers our users flexibility for customization and tuning for different selection and layer needs. This new pattern selection solution, connected with ASML Brion’s MXP (Metrology of eXtreme Performance) contour fidelity gauges and superior, accurate Newron (deep learning) resist model, fulfills the advanced technology node demands for OPC modeling, thus offering full chip prediction power.
The semiconductor design node shrinking requires tighter edge placement errors (EPE) budget. OPC error, as one major contributor of EPE budget, need to be reduced with better OPC model accuracy. In addition, the CD (Critical Dimension) shrinkage in advanced node heavily relies on the etch process. Therefore AEI (After Etch Inspection) metrology and modeling are important to provide accurate pattern correction and optimization. For nodes under 14nm, the etch bias (i.e. the bias between ADI (After Development Inspection) CD and AEI CD) could be -10 nm ~ -50 nm, with a strong loading and aspect-ratio dependency. Etch behavior in advanced node is very complicated and brings challenges to conventional rule based OPC correction. Therefore, accurate etch modeling becomes more and more important to make precise prediction of final complex shapes on wafer for OPC correction. In order to ensure the accuracy of etch modeling, high quality metrology is necessary to reduce random error and systematic measurement error. Moreover, CD gauges alone are not sufficient to capture all the effects of the etch process on different patterns. Edge placement (EP) gauges that accurately describe the contour shapes at various key positions are needed. In this work we used the AEI SEM images obtained from traditional CD-SEM flow, processed with ASML’s MXP (Metrology for eXtreme Performance) tool, and used the extracted CD gauges and massive EP gauges to train a deeplearning Newron Etch model. In the approach, MXP reduced the AEI metrology random errors and shape fitting measurement error and provides better pattern coverage with massive reliable CD and EP gauges, Newron Etch captures complex and unknown physical and chemical effects learned from wafer data. Results shows that MXP successfully extracted stable contour from AEI SEM for various pattern types. Three etch models are calibrated and compared: CD based EEB model (Effective Etch Bias), CD+EP based EEB model, and CD+EP based Newron etch model. CD based EEB model captures the major trend of the etch process. Including EP gauges helps EEB model with about 10% RMS reduction on prediction. Integration of MXP (CD+EP) and Newron Etch model gains about 45% prediction RMS reduction compared to baseline model. The good prediction of Newron Etch is also verified from wafer SEM overlay on complex-shape patterns. This result validates the effectiveness of ASML’s solution of deep learning etch model integration with MXP AEI’s massive wafer data extraction from etch process, and will help to provide accurate and reliable etch modeling for advanced node etch OPC correction in semiconductor manufacturing.
The semiconductor manufacturing roadmap which generally follows Moore’s law requires smaller and smaller EPE (Edge Placement Error), and this places stricter requirements on OPC model accuracy, which is mainly limited by metrology errors, pattern coverage and model form. Current metrology errors are mainly related to SEM image noise and measurement difficulty in complex 2D patterns. And traditional model form improvement by adding empirical terms for PEB (Post Exposure Bake), NTD (Negative Tone Development) and PRS (Physical Resist Shrinkage) effects still cannot meet the accuracy spec because other physical and chemical effects are uncaptured. Fitting these effects also requires comprehensive pattern coverage during model calibration. Solely improving model form may overfit the metrology error, which is risky, while solely improving metrology ignores existing model errors: both factors are troublesome for OPC. In this paper, a new metrology (MXP, naming for Metrology of Extreme Performance) and deep learning (Newron, naming for a Deep Convolutional Neural Network model form) integrated solution is proposed, where MXP decreases the metrology errors and provides good pattern coverage with high-volume reliable CD and EP (Edge Placement) gauges, and Newron captures remaining complex physical and chemical effects embedded in high-volume gauges beyond the traditional model. This solution shows overall ~30% prediction accuracy improvement compared to baseline metrology and FEM+ (Focus Exposure Matrix) model flow in N14 NTD process, predicts SEM shape of critical weak points more accurately.
As the design node of memory device shrinks, OPC model accuracy is becoming ever more critical from development to manufacturing. To improve the model accuracy, more and more physical effects are analyzed and terms for those physical effects are added. But it is unachievable to capture the complete physical effects. In this study, deep neural network is employed and studied to improve model accuracy. Regularization is achieved using physical guidance model. To address overfitting issue, high volume of contour based edge placement (EP) gauges (>10K) are generated using fast eBeam tool (eP5) and metrology processing software (MXP) without increasing turnaround time. It is shown that the new approach improved model accuracy by >47% compared to traditional approach on >1.4K verification gauges.
Classical SEM metrology, CD-SEM, uses low data rate and extensive frame-averaging technique to achieve high-quality SEM imaging for high-precision metrology. The drawbacks include prolonged data collection time and larger photoresist shrinkage due to excess electron dosage. This paper will introduce a novel e-beam metrology system based on a high data rate, large probe current, and ultra-low noise electron optics design. At the same level of metrology precision, this high speed e-beam metrology system could significantly shorten data collection time and reduce electron dosage. In this work, the data collection speed is higher than 7,000 images per hr. Moreover, a novel large field of view (LFOV) capability at high resolution was enabled by an advanced electron deflection system design. The area coverage by LFOV is >100x larger than classical SEM. Superior metrology precision throughout the whole image has been achieved, and high quality metrology data could be extracted from full field. This new capability on metrology will further improve metrology data collection speed to support the need for large volume of metrology data from OPC model calibration of next generation technology. The shrinking EPE (Edge Placement Error) budget places more stringent requirement on OPC model accuracy, which is increasingly limited by metrology errors. In the current practice of metrology data collection and data processing to model calibration flow, CD-SEM throughput becomes a bottleneck that limits the amount of metrology measurements available for OPC model calibration, impacting pattern coverage and model accuracy especially for 2D pattern prediction. To address the trade-off in metrology sampling and model accuracy constrained by the cycle time requirement, this paper employs the high speed e-beam metrology system and a new computational software solution to take full advantage of the large volume data and significantly reduce both systematic and random metrology errors. The new computational software enables users to generate large quantity of highly accurate EP (Edge Placement) gauges and significantly improve design pattern coverage with up to 5X gain in model prediction accuracy on complex 2D patterns. Overall, this work showed >2x improvement in OPC model accuracy at a faster model turn-around time.
The extension of optical lithography to 7 nm node and beyond relies heavily on multiple litho-etch patterning technologies. The etch processes in multiple patterning often require progressively large bias differences between litho and etch as the target features become smaller. Moreover, since this litho-etch bias has strong pattern dependency, it must be taken into consideration during the Optical Proximity Correction (OPC) processes. Traditionally, two approaches are used to compensate etch biases: rule-based retargeting and model-based retargeting. The rule-based approach has a turn-around-time advantage but now has challenges meeting the increasingly tighter critical dimension (CD) requirements using a reasonable etch-bias table, especially for complex 2D patterns. Alternatively, model-based retargeting can meet these CD requirements by capturing the etch process physics with high accuracy, including the etch bias variability that arises from both patterning proximity effects and etch chamber non-uniformity. In the past, empirical terms have been used to approximate the etch bias due to pattern proximity effects but sometimes empirical models are known to have compromised model accuracy so a physical based approach is desired. This paper’s work will address the etch bias variability due to patterning proximity effects by using a physical approach based simplified chemical kinetics. It starts from a well calibrated After-Development-Inspection (ADI) model and the subsequent etch model is based on the ADI model contour. By assuming that plasma chemical species in the trenches are maintained in an equilibrium state, the plasma species act on the edges to induce etch bias. Methods are developed to evaluate plasma collision probability on trench edges for random layouts. Furthermore, the impact of resist materials on etch bias are treated with Arrhenius equation or as a second order reaction. Equations governing plasma collision probabilities on trench edges as a function of time are derived. An etch bias model can be calibrated based on those equations. Experimental results have shown that this physical approach to model etch bias is a promising direction to applications for full-chip etch proximity corrections.
Strong resist shrinkage effects have been widely observed in resist profiles after negative tone development (NTD) and therefore must be taken into account in computational lithography applications. However, existing lithography simulation tools, especially those designed for full-chip applications, lack resist shrinkage modeling capabilities because they are not needed until only recently when NTD processes begin to replace the conventional positive tone development (PTD) processes where resist shrinkage effects are negligible. In this work we describe the development of a physical resist shrinkage (PRS) model for full-chip lithography simulations and present its accuracy evaluation against experimental data.
Over the years, Lithography Engineers continue to focus on CD control, overlay and process capability to meet current node requirements for yield and device performance. Reducing or eliminating variability in any process will have significant impact, but the sources of variability in any lithography process are many. The goal from the light source manufacturer is to further enable capability and reduce variation through a number of parameters. (1, 2, 3, 4)
Recent improvements in bandwidth control have been realized in the XLR platform with Cymer’s DynaPulseTM control technology. This reduction in bandwidth variation translates in the further reduction of CD variation in device structures 5,6. The Authors will review the methodology for determining the impact that bandwidth variation has on CD dose, focus, pitch and bandwidth, which is required to build a dynamic model. This assists in understanding the impact that bandwidth variability has on the accuracy of the Source and Mask optimization and the overall OPC model, which is reviewed and demonstrated.
KEYWORDS: Scanning electron microscopy, Data modeling, Atomic force microscopy, Calibration, Data centers, 3D modeling, Lithography, Photoresist processing, Double patterning technology, Electron beam lithography
The pursuit of ever smaller transistors has pushed technological innovations in the field of lithography. In order
to continue following the path of Moore’s law, several solutions have been proposed: EUV, e-beam and double
patterning lithography. As EUV and e-beam lithography are still not ready for mass production for 20 nm and 14 nm
nodes, double patterning lithography play an important role for these nodes. In this work, we focus on a Self-Aligned
Double-Patterning process (SADP) which consists of depositing a spacer material on each side of a mandrel exposed
during a first lithography step, dividing the pitch into two, after being transferred into the substrate, and then cutting the
unwanted patterns through a second lithography exposure.
In the specific case where spacers are deposited directly on the flanks of the resist, it is crucial to control its
profile as it could induce final CD errors or even spacer collapse. One possibility to prevent these defects from occurring
is to predict the profile of the resist at the OPc verification stage. For that, we need an empirical resist model that is able
to predict such behaviour.
This work is a study of a profile-aware resist model that is calibrated using both atomic force microscopy
(AFM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) data, both taken using a focus and exposure matrix (FEM).
3D lithography simulations capable of modeling 3D effects in all lithographic processes are becoming critical in OPC
and verification applications as semiconductor feature sizes continue to shrink. These effects include mask topography,
resist profile and wafer topography. In this work we present an efficient computational framework for full-chip 3D
lithography simulations. Since fast modeling of mask topography effects has been studied for many years and is a
relatively mature area, we will only briefly review a full-chip 3D mask model, Tachyon M3D, to highlight the
importance and modeling requirements for accurate prediction of best focus variations among different device features
induced by mask topography. We will focus our discussions on a full-chip 3D resist model, Tachyon R3D, its derivation
and simplification from a full physical resist model. The resulting model form is fully compatible with the existing 2D
resist model with added capabilities for resist profile and top loss prediction. A benchmark against the full physical
model will be presented as well. We will also describe the development of a full-chip 3D wafer topography model,
Tachyon W3D, and the preliminary results against rigorous simulations.
Computational lithography (CL) is becoming more and more of a fundamental enabler of advanced semiconductor
processing technology, and new requirements for CL models are arising from new applications such as model-based
process tuning. In this paper we study the impact of realistic machine parameters that can be incorporated in a modern
CL model, and provide an experimental assessment of model improvements with respect to prediction of scanner tuning
effects. The data demonstrates improved model accuracy and prediction by inclusion of scanner-type specific modeling
capabilities and machine data in the CL model building process. In addition to scanner effects, we study laser bandwidth
tuning effects and the accuracy of corresponding model predictions by comparison against experimental data. The data
demonstrate that the models predict well wafer CD variations resulting from laser BW tuning. We also find that using
realistic spectral density distribution of the laser can provide more accurate results than the commonly assumed modified
Lorentzian line shape.
The usage of conventional OPC models traditionally was confined to the specific process conditions at which the models
were. Separable models for computational lithography (CL), including OPC and post-OPC layout verification, allow
extrapolation of the calibrated model and accurate prediction at process conditions different from the exact settings used
for model calibration. This capability enables significantly reduced turnaround time in early process development, and it
opens the way for new applications such as model based process optimization. It relies on sufficiently accurate modeling
of litho process components as separate subsystems, in particular mask, scanner optics, and resist process. Inclusion of
actual machine parameters of the exposure tool in the optical model can improve model accuracy and predictability,
while 'actual machine parameters' may represent either a specific scanner type or an individual exposure tool. We study
the impact of machine parameters that can be incorporated in a modern computational litho model, by analyzing their
relative effect on predicted CD measurements and extract a ranking in terms of their expected benefit for model
separability. An experimental study demonstrates improved model accuracy and separability by inclusion of either
scanner-type specific model data or individual machine-specific metrology data in the CL model building process.
The challenge for the upcoming full-chip CD uniformity (CDU) control at 32nm and 22nm nodes is unprecedented with
expected specifications never before attempted in semiconductor manufacturing. To achieve these requirements, OPC
models not only must be accurate for full-chip process window characterization for fine-tuning and matching of the
existing processes and exposure tools, but also be trust-worthy and predictive to enable processes to be developed in
advance of next-generation photomasks, exposure tools, and resists. This new OPC requirement extends beyond the
intended application scope for behavior-lumped models. Instead, separable OPC models are better suited, such that each
model stage represents the physics and chemistry more completely in order to maintain reliable prediction accuracy. The
resist, imaging tool, and mask models must each stand independently, allowing existing resist and mask models to be
combined with new optics models based on exposure settings other than the one calibrated previously.
In this paper, we assess multiple sets of experimental data that demonstrate the ability of the TachyonTM FEM (focus and
exposure modeling) to separate the modeling of mask, optics, and resists. We examine the predictability improvements
of using 3D mask models to replace thin mask model and the use of measured illumination source versus top-hat types.
Our experimental wafer printing results show that OPC models calibrated in FEM to one optical setting can be
extrapolated to different optical settings, with prediction accuracy commensurate with the calibration accuracy. We see
up to 45% improvement with the measured illumination source, and up to 30% improvement with 3D mask.
Additionally, we observe evidence of thin mask resist models that are compensating for 3D mask effect in our wafer data
by as much as 60%.
A novel device of tandem multiple quantum wells (MQWs) electroabsorption modulators (EAMs) monolithically integrated with DFB laser is fabricated by ultra-low-pressure (22 mbar) selective area growth (SAG) MOCVD technique. Experimental results exhibit superior device characteristics with low threshold of 19 mA, output light power of 4.5 mW, and over 20 dB extinction ratio when coupled into a single mode fiber. Moreover, over 10 GHz modulation bandwidth is developed with a driving voltage of 2 V. Using this sinusoidal voltage driven integrated device, 10GHz repetition rate pulse with a width of 13.7 ps without any compression elements is obtained.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.