To avoid expensive immersion lithography and to further use existing dry tools for critical contact layer lithography at
4Xnm DRAM nodes the application of altPSM is investigated and compared to attPSM. Simulations and experiments
with several test masks showed that by use of altPSM with suitable 0°/180° coloring and assist placement 30nm smaller
contacts can be resolved through pitch with sufficient process windows (PW). This holds for arrays of contacts with
variable lengths through short and long side pitches. A further benefit is the lower mask error enhancement factor
(MEEF). Nevertheless 3D mask errors (ME) consume benefits in the PW and the assist placement and coloring of the
main features (MF) put some constraints on the chip design. An altPSM compatible 4Xnm full-chip layout was realized
without loss of chip area. Mask making showed very convincing results with respect to CDU, etch depth uniformity and
defectiveness. The printed intra-field CD uniformity was comparable to attPSM despite the smaller target CDs. Room for
improvement is identified in OPC accuracy and in automatic assist placement and sizing.
We present rigorous 3D EMF simulations of isolated features on photomasks using a newly developed finite-element
method. We report on the current status of the finite-element solver JCMsuite, incorporating higher-order
edge elements, adaptive refinement methods, and fast solution algorithms. We demonstrate that rigorous
and accurate results on light scattering off isolated features can be achived at relatively low computational cost,
compared to the standard approach of simulations on large-pitch, periodic computational domains.
Rigorous computer simulations of propagating electromagnetic fields have become an important tool for optical
metrology and optics design of nanostructured components. As has been shown in previous benchmarks some of
the presently used methods suffer from low convergence rates and/or low accuracy of the results and exhibit very
long computation times1, 2 which makes application to extended 2D layout patterns impractical. We address 3D
simulation tasks by using a finite-element solver which has been shown to be superior to competing methods by
several orders of magnitude in accuracy and computational time for typical microlithography simulations.2 We
report on the current status of the solver, incorporating higher order edge elements, adaptive refinement methods,
and fast solution algorithms. Further, we investigate the performance of the solver in the 3D simulation project
of light diffraction off an alternating phase-shift contact-hole mask.
For immersion technology the mask is illuminated under large angles and the features sizes are approaching the
illuminating wavelength. At such operating conditions, several publications have shown rigorous diffraction effects
having a noticeable effect on the aerial image. For the Kirchhoff assumption, which is commonly employed in
lithography simulation, the mask is assumed to be an infinity thin transparency. This assumption implies the diffracted
spectrum to be independent of the incident illumination angle and no coupling between polarization states occurs. This
work is a fundamental study to deepen the understanding of rigorous off-axis effects for current and future mask
technologies. This paper will show simulation studies for standard attenuated- and alternating mask gratings, which look
at the diffracted spectrum of a mask grating with respect to polarization orientation and off-axis angle of the illuminating
wave.
We perform 3D lithography simulations by using a finite-element
solver.
To proof applicability to real 3D problems we investigate
DUV light propagation through a structure of size 9μm x 4μm x 65nm.
On this relatively large computational domain we
perform rigorous computations (No Hopkins) taking into account
a grid of 11 x 21 source points with two polarization directions
each.
We obtain well converged results with an accuracy of the
diffraction orders of about 1%.
The results compare well to experimental aerial imaging results.
We further investigate the convergence of 3D solutions towards
quasi-exact results obtained with different methods.
Alternating Phase-Shifting masks (altPSM) are known to provide high contrast imaging combined with a low Mask Error Enhancement Factor (MEEF) at low k1. At feature sizes close to 60nm half-pitch and less the impact of mask topography effects increases. This applies in particular for altPSM. This is due to the quartz etch which is required for every second mask aperture to obtain the 180 degrees phase shift. It enlarges the mask profile height significantly. The influence of the quartz trench profile on the transmission and phase balancing performance has already been studied extensively. Basically it has been shown, that tighter quartz trench profile control, specifically for etch depth and width, is required with decreasing mask feature half pitch. The desired mask pattern geometry optimization is currently based on an evaluation of the printed resist pattern over defocus. However, a mask process engineer can use instead only AIMS measurements of the mask features. Therefore there is a mature interest to check, how good such measurements can replace resist pattern measurements. In the paper therefore it is evaluated how accurate AIMS measurements can describe the real printing performance of an alternating PSM in resist. Impact of differences of the image formation is investigated by use of analytical expressions. Furthermore, the influence of tool imperfections and the presence of resist are discussed. The theoretical results are compared to experimental data taken from AIMS measurements and wafer prints.
For the technology development of microlithography various optical simulation tools are established as a planning and development tool. Depending on the application, various numerical approximation schemes are used to tradeoff accuracy versus speed. Determining the correct numerical setting is often a tricky task as it is a compromise between these two contrary properties. In our study, we compare the numerical accuracy of two optical simulators, Solid-E as a representative for simulators for technology development and Mentor Calibre as design-for-manufacturing and optical proximity correction (OPC) tool. Calibre uses a coherent kernel approximation for performing fast simulations. As a measure for the simulation accuracy, we use the root-mean-square error criterion of a linearity curve compared to an analytical reference simulation.
The annotation of electrical information or constraints is a well established method to transfer information on design intent from the electrical to the physical designer. In this paper, we will discuss the possibility to extend the concept of annotation as vehicle to hand over critical information from the physical designer to the resolution enhancement technique (RET) engineer. Opportunities and implications to extend the existing optical proximity correction (OPC) methods from the current stage of "just print the layout on wafer" towards new approaches where the layout can be optimized during the RET/OPC step based on designers input are discussed. In addition, the benefit of using process variation information for this layout optimization will be compared to a conventional OPC approach that just tries to realize an overlapping process window at one point of the process window. The power of a combination of both approaches will be shown, based on a small test case. The target of this work is to motivate further research and development in this direction to enhance the current OPC/RET capabilities towards a more integrated solution enabling annotated layout optimization as link between design and manufacturing.
An extremely fast time-harmonic finite element solver developed for the transmission analysis of photonic crystals was applied to mask simulation problems. The applicability was proven by examining a set of typical problems and by a benchmarking against two established methods (FDTD and a differential method) and an analytical example. The new finite element approach was up to 100 times faster than the competing approaches for moderate target accuracies, and it was the only method which allowed to reach high target accuracies.
For leading mask technologies the mask inspection for finding critical defects is always a difficult task. With the introduction of chrome-less, high-transmission and alternating mask types, new absorber material and the possibility of quartz defects the defect inspection and -classification becomes even more challenging. To decide whether a defect is critical or a repair is successful, the Zeiss AIMS tool is used to classify defects. For conventional imaging the optical settings are usually chosen such that resolution is maximized, for example a dipole illumination is used for imaging a dense line-space array at an optimum contrast. In this paper we will do the opposite and reduce the optical resolution, such that we can filter out the array pattern and study the resulting defect image. This technique allows using a simple threshold detector to find and classify defects.
The shrink roadmap of semiconductors results in tighter specification of the wafer structures. Besides technological advancement and tighter tolerances for mask and scanner technology, it also requires an improvement of the numerical- and modeling accuracy of lithography simulation and proximity correction software. The modeling of high NA polarization effects and reflections within the resist stack are taken into account by current simulation models. Tool vendors support modeling accuracy by characterizing optical parameters of the scanners by measurement of the lens aberrations and the illumination pupil. The goal of this paper is to provide an algorithm, which allows achieving higher numerical accuracy by being able to use bitmaps with higher resolution for lens and illumination pupil at reasonable computational speed. While the focus of this paper is on optical lithography, the method itself is also of interest for the simulation of scanning laser microscopy such as optical disks or mask inspection.
The lithographic potential of various mask types for the printing of 65nm features has been investigated by simulation and experimentation. As key parameters process window, mask error enhancement factor, balancing performance, and phase and CD error susceptibility have been analyzed. Alternating chromeless phase-shifting masks (PSM) show the smallest mask error enhancement factor (MEEF), but the largest phase and CD error sensitivity. Alternating PSM have a larger MEEF but require less tight mask specifications. Double edge chromeless PSM combine small MEEF value with relaxed phase and CD control specifications when an appropriate illumination is chosen. Good intra-field CD control and sufficient large process window for 65nm pattern can be obtained for this mask type. The impact of aberrations and pupil imperfections on the CD control has been investigated. The mask processes will be discussed and mask performance data introduced.
In modern mask manufacturing, a successful defect mitigation strategy has been become crucial to achieve defect free masks for high-end lithography. The basic steps of such a strategy include inspection, repair, and subsequent post-repair qualification of repair sites. For the latter task, actinic aerial image measurements have been proven to be the technique of choice to assess the printability of a repaired site. In the last three years, International SEMATECH in cooperation with Infineon/AMTC-Dresden and SELETE, funded a joint development project at Carl Zeiss to develop an AIMS tool operating at the 157nm wavelength. The three beta tools were shipped in 2003 to the three beta customer sites. In this paper are presented the first results obtained with these beta tools, including measurements on binary as well as alternating phase shift masks. The technical properties of the tool were discussed with regards to the capability of the tool for defect qualification on photomasks. Additionally, preliminary results of the evaluation of alternating phase shift masks will be discussed, including measurements performed on dense lines-and-spaces structures with various pitch sizes.
Mask characterization and qualification are becoming more and more difficult for high-end and alternating phase shifting masks. One choice is to use indirect methods like as SEM/AFM measurements to characterize mask performance. The indirect measurement has the disadvantage that the measured CD is not the true merit function. It is therefore tempting to use optical methods to characterize masks. The Zeiss AIMS (Aerial Image Measurement System) microscope is particular appealing for this task since it simulates the lithographic imaging optics. The key problem is the reliability and repeatability of the resulting AIMS measurements. The quality of the measurement depends strongly on the tool characteristic such as illumination stability and operator skill, e.g. for focus adjustment.
In this paper we discuss the application of image processing and Fourier analysis techniques to AIMS images of periodic structures. By computing the Fourier series coefficients one obtains a very compact but complete description of the AIMS image over defocus. This computation and interpretation of the series coefficients allows to compensate many error influences such as mask rotation, tool magnification and focus adjustment. The algorithm is demonstrated on COG and alt. phase shifting mask measurements for a wavelength of 193nm and compared to the results obtained by simulation.
With alternating phase shift masks (altPSM) an enhancement technique is available to realize smaller design rules. Meanwhile the basic production process for this mask type is well known and established for 193nm technology development. The qualification of the masks is now in the focus of development work. Sensitive defect inspection is essential for the qualification of altPSMs. In addition accurate phase and transmission balancing measurement technique has to be applied. In this paper we are presenting a detailed defect printability study for sub-100nm feature size technology at 193nm wavelength. Programmed quartz defects with different shapes and sizes were designed. They were implemented in a lines/spaces altPSM design. The processed quartz defects were characterized with a scanning electron microscope and an arial imaging microscope system. The printing behavior of the defects was analyzed after wafer exposures. In addition the required sensitivity for the altPSM inspection was evaluated. Finally the inspection sensitivity was characterized and optimized with programmed and production like defects.
The lithographic potential of alternating PSM for sub-100nm gate patterning have been evaluated in comparison to alternative techniques. The status of the key elements of the full level alternating PSM approach including design conversion, optical proximity correction, mask making, double exposure and phase-shifting mask imaging will be demonstrated for a 256MDRAM device. Experimental data describing the phase-shifting mask quality, the lithographic process windows and the CD control obtained for alternating PSM in full level and array only approach will be presented.
In this paper, we present a process of balancing the aerial image and analyzing the results of resist images of 157-nm alternating PSM with a 0.85 NA lens. The mask is made by dual trench technique with a phase-etch of 115nm and an isotropic under-etch of 90nm as predicted by simulations. With this dual trenched mask, the wafer printing images show tremendous improvement on “line walking” or “line paring” phenomena. The ultimate resolution is 60nm dense line. The focus latitude is around 0.1 to 0.15 um. We also used a 157-nm AIMS tool to check intensity balance. The results supports balanced intensity of this mask. For mask quality characterization, etch depth is measured by AFM and mask CD is measured by CD SEM. The uniformity of etching depth and mask CD are all within specifications. We also present some abnormal CD variation across line array observed during this investigation. The results from this work give a good groundwork of 157-nm capability of alternating PSM and 157-nm resist imaging quality.
In optical lithography balancing the aerial image of an alternating phase shifting mask (alt. PSM) is a major challenge. For the exposure wavelengths (currently 248nm and 193nm) an optimum etching method is necessary to overcome imbalance effects. Defects play an important role in the imbalances of the aerial image. In this contribution defects will be discussed by using the methodology of global phase imbalance control also for local imbalances which are a result of quartz defects. The effective phase error can be determined with an AIMS-system by measuring the CD width between the images of deep- and shallow trenches at different focus settings. The AIMS results are analyzed in comparison to the simulated and lithographic print results of the alternating structures. For the analysis of local aerial image imbalances it is necessary to investigate the capability of detecting these phase defects with state of the art inspection systems. Alternating PSMs containing programmed defects were inspected with different algorithms to investigate the capture rate of special phase defects in dependence on the defect size. Besides inspection also repair of phase defects is an important task. In this contribution we show the effect of repair on the optical behavior of phase defects. Due to the limited accuracy of the repair tools the repaired area still shows a certain local phase error. This error can be caused either by residual quartz material or a substrate damage. The influence of such repair induced phase errors on the aerial image were investigated.
Besides assist features in combination with HTPSM (half-tone phase shifting mask} and off-axis illumination altPSM (alternating phase shifting mask} is the major resolution enhancement technique to extend optical lithography to low k1. AltPSM in addition has the potential of superior CD control. However to achieve this in production altPSM has to fullfil a number of specifications with respect to phase and transmission. Another important aspect to obtain maximum CD control and overlapping process window for all kinds of structures at different pitches is that the phase shifters need to be optimized. Optimizing shifters by means of simulation results provides valuable input for both setting up design rules for altPSM application and for development of OPC strategies and software. Therefore various systems with different widths of lines and shifters were studied with special focus on basic asymmetric cases. We applied Solid-CM TM, a 3D EMF (electro magnetic field) simulator for our studies. Some results obtained from simulation were experimentally verified by wafer printing results (SEM imaging and CD measurement}. In addition, comparison to 2D simulation results clearly allows the determination of cases in which 3D effects have to be taken into account. The effect of varying shifters is monitored by pattern placement and process window analysis. We apply this investigation to develop solution strategies and to optimize shifter dimensions.
Besides halftone phase shifting masks (HTPSM) in combination with off-axis illumination alternating phase shifting masks (altPSM) are becoming more and more an important resolution enhancement technique. Their obvious benefits can only yield profit in production if certain mask properties like intensity and phase balance are controlled to a requisite extent. In order to achieve production capable masks within a reasonable time and cost frame simulation tools are of essential importance for mask development and manufacturing. Four our studies we employed solid-CMTM, a 3D EMF (electro magnetic field) simulator that handles arbitrary topographical masks. It is demonstrated by examples that these capabilities are mandatory for altPSM development. In this paper we discuss the effects of various issues relevant for development and manufacturing of altPSM on a basis of systematic 3D EMF simulations. For different balancing options sensitivity to phase errors, mask CD errors and pitch/feature size were investigated. Comparisons to 2D simulation are made for further illustration. We show the influence of certain mask errors on process window and draw conclusions for optimizing altPSM manufacturing.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.