On-product overlay (OPO) control in the DRAM process has become a critical component from node to node to produce high device yield. To meet OPO node goals, Non-Zero Offset (NZO) and its stability across lots must be monitored and controlled. NZO is the bias between overlay (OVL) on-target measurement at After Development Inspection (ADI) vs. on-device measurement at After Etching Inspection (AEI). In this paper, we will present Imaging-Based Overlay (IBO) metrology data at ADI of two different marks, segmented AIM® with design rule patterns and robust AIM (rAIM®) with Moiré effect with a small pitch. NZO analysis will be presented for each target type including basic performance.
With the continuous shrinking of semiconductor device nodes, the reduction of on-product overlay (OPO) becomes extremely critical for high-yield IC (Integrated Circuit) manufacturing. This requires accurate overlay (OVL) process control which can be better achieved by using an optimized OVL target design and a more advanced metrology platform. The novel rAIM® imaging-based-overlay (IBO) target, which has a grating-over-grating structure with significantly smaller pitch sizes as compared to the standard advanced-imaging-metrology (AIM®) target, can improve OVL measurement accuracy by adopting a more device-compatible design with high Moiré sensitivity. This paper demonstrates the advantages of rAIM targets by comparing and quantifying their performance to standard AIM targets through key parameters including raw OVL, residuals, precision, and total measurement uncertainty (TMU). We also present the performance of rAIM targets on different OVL metrology platforms. We conclude that with an optimized target design and an advanced OVL measurement platform, rAIM targets can be an ideal overlay metrology solution for advanced dynamic random-access memory (DRAM) devices.
In recent years, the 3D NAND stack has continued to expand rapidly in the Z direction with tighter process windows, while deck-to-deck overlay faces increasing measurability and accuracy challenges. Meanwhile, thick opaque hard mask (HM) has been utilized in several layers, thus downgrades a lot of mark contrast and introduces large process variation (PV). To meet tightened overlay requirements, KLA’s Metrology Target Design (MTD) assisted by simulation analysis has become an important part of the holistic overlay improvement solution set. Compared to the conventional target design simulation process in which the target stack is built up with a standard template, in this work, a customized template was designed to fit actual mark behavior. Using this new template, more accurate simulation to measurement (S2M) matching was demonstrated, which makes the new target design more reliable. With this added benefit, the newly designed target achieved desirable residual improvement with better on-product overlay (OPO) performance. In the case of the challenging thick opaque HM layer, target segmentation and CD/Pitch optimization by simulation also significantly improved mark contrast and OPO using the newly designed mark. Along with contrast gain, the robustness against large PV of the simulated mark was increased by quantifying comprehensive PV on product wafers. Furthermore, with the verification of the measured data, simulation data can be used to establish a more thorough representation of the process characteristics and parametric sensitive virtual metrology, targeted to meet the goals of maximizing overlay accuracy in the 3D NAND process.
In this paper, the rAIMTM (robust AIM) overlay target was investigated in terms of the stability versus the POR AIM® (Advanced Imaging Metrology) target used for imaging-based overlay (IBO) measurement at after development inspection (ADI). The targets were designed using KLA’s MTD AcuRate™, metrology target design software that performs simulations based on the optical properties related to relative permittivity and permeability about the material of each of the layers. Using advanced device layers, we studied the performance of the POR AIM target versus the newly designed rAIM target for imaging-based overlay measurements. For each target, we quantified the optical contrast, kernel signal, correctable modeled terms, total measurement uncertainty (TMU), and overlay (OVL) residuals from the modeled data through various wavelengths inside the Moiré effect regime in the case of rAIM. We demonstrate that there is an OVL measurement performance improvement using the rAIM target versus the POR AIM target. The measured optical properties of the rAIM target and comparison to the POR AIM target will be presented.
As design nodes of advanced semiconductor chips shrink, reduction in on-product overlay (OPO) budget becomes more critical to achieving higher yield. Imaging-based overlay (IBO) targets usually consist of periodic patterns where their pitches are resolvable with visible light microscopy. The difference between the feature dimensions of the device and the optical target is growing as device design nodes shrink. To make the optical target emulate the device as much as possible, the target’s feature periodicity is reduced. Using this approach, the process impact on the device is simulated on the overlay target which enables a more accurate measurement on grid (target) in terms of OPO matching. To further optimize IBO performance, a new moiré effect based robust Advanced Imaging Mode (rAIM™) target design was developed. This rAIM IBO target is implemented using significantly smaller pitches compared to the standard AIM® target, resulting in a more device-like target design. In this paper we investigate the benefits of the optical improvement, manifested as the target gain, and the process compatibility benefits to improve the target accuracy, robustness, and measurability to meet overlay (OVL) basic performance requirements, such as total measurement uncertainty (TMU).
Reduction in on product overlay (OPO) is a key component for high-end, high yield integrated circuit manufacturing. Due to the continually shrinking dimensions of the IC device elements it has become near-impossible to measure overlay on the device itself, driving the need to perform overlay measurements on dedicated overlay targets. In order to enable accurate measurement on grid (target) in terms of OPO matching, the overlay mark must be as similar as possible to the device in order to mimic the process impact on the device. Imaging-based optical overlay (IBO) provides the best accuracy and robustness for overlay metrology measurements for many process layers. To further optimize IBO performance, a new robust AIM (rAIM™) IBO target design was developed, using the Moiré effect. rAIM is implemented using significantly smaller pitches compared with the standard AIM® target, hence providing a more device-like target design. This new target design has the potential to improve target accuracy and robustness, to improve measurability, and to meet overlay basic performance requirements, such as total measurement uncertainty (TMU).
In recent years, simulation-based analysis has become an integral phase in metrology targets design process, performances optimization wise to support on product overlay (OPO) reduction, accuracy and robustness to process variation. Moreover, a simulated unit (stack) represented by its optical and geometrical properties can be used as a mathematicalphysical object for obtaining a deeper understanding of the issues faced while an actual measurement performed. Location based stack calibration allows for both, symmetrical and asymmetrical process variation, a noticeable wafer signature to be attained. Using this information, one can analyze the target-design process-compatibility and asymmetry stability. Furthermore, simulated data can be used, combined with measured data, to establish a more exhaustive perceiving of the process characteristics and risks, hence maxims the measurement performances and stability of the process and target behavior. Likewise, simulation tools can equip integration teams with a more holistic apprehension and quantified data, prior or along real time measurements. In the paper we will cover the simulation theory, use-cases and results.
KEYWORDS: Metrology, Optical parametric oscillators, Optical design, Overlay metrology, 3D acquisition, 3D metrology, Integrated circuits, Manufacturing, Logic, Process control
On product overlay (OPO) shrink is a key enabler to achieve high yield in integrated circuit manufacturing. One of the key factors to enable accurate measurement on grid (target) is the use of optimized overlay (OVL) mark design to achieve low OPO. The OVL mark design enables accurate and robust OVL metrology and improves measurability and basic performance requirements such as total measurement uncertainty (TMU). In this paper, we demonstrate the methodology of mark design for different devices based on simulations, measurements and verification. We compare OVL performance of AIM® targets and grating-over-grating imaging targets utilizing the Moiré effect. Methodologies described in this work utilize robust AIM (rAIM™) targets, target design from the MTD AcuRate™ simulation-based OVL metrology target design tool, and the Archer™ OVL metrology system.
Overlay process control is a critical aspect of integrated circuit manufacturing. Advanced DRAM manufacturing overlay error budget approaches the sub-2nm threshold, including all sources of overlay error: litho processing, non-litho processing, metrology error, etc. Overlay measurement quality, both for accuracy and robustness, depends on the metrology system and its recipe setup. The optimal configuration depends on the layer and materials involved. Increased flexibility of metrology setup is of paramount importance, paired with improved methods of recipe optimization.
Both optical image-based overlay (IBO) and scatterometry diffraction overlay (SCOL®) are necessary tools for overlay control. For some devices and layers IBO provides the best accuracy and robustness, while on others SCOL provides optimum metrology. Historically, wavelength selection was limited to discrete wavelengths and at only a single wavelength. At advanced nodes IBO and SCOL require wavelength tunability and multiple wavelengths to optimize accuracy and robustness, as well as options for polarization and numerical aperture (NA). In previous studies1,2,3 we investigated wavelength tunability analysis with landscape analysis, using analytic techniques to determine the optimal setup. In this report we show advancements in the landscape analysis technique for IBO through both focus and wavelength, and comparisons to SCOL. A key advantage of imaging is the ability to optimize wavelength on a per-layer basis. This can be a benefit for EUV layers in combination with those of 193i, for example, as well as other applications such as thick 3D NAND layers. The goal is to make accurate and robust overlay metrology that is immune from process stack variations, and to provide metrics that indicate the quality of metrology performance. Through both simulation and on-wafer advanced DRAM measurements, we show quantitative benefits of accuracy and robustness to process stack variability for IBO and SCOL applications.
Methodologies described in this work can be achieved using Archer™ overlay metrology systems, ATL™ overlay metrology systems, and 5D Analyzer® advanced data analysis and patterning control solution.
In overlay (OVL) metrology the quality of measurements and the resulting reported values depend heavily on the measurement setup used. For example, in scatterometry OVL (SCOL) metrology a specific target may be measured with multiple illumination setups, including several apodization options, two possible laser polarizations, and multiple possible laser wavelengths. Not all possible setups are suitable for the metrology method as different setups can yield significantly different performance in terms of the accuracy and robustness of the reported OVL values. Finding an optimal measurement setup requires great flexibility in measurement, to allow for high-resolution landscape mapping (mapping the dependence of OVL, other metrics, and details of pupil images on measurement setup). This can then be followed by a method for analyzing the landscape and selecting an accurate and robust measurement setup. The selection of an optimal measurement setup is complicated by the sensitivity of metrology to variations in the fabrication process (process variations) such as variations in layer thickness or in the properties of target symmetry. The metrology landscape changes with process variations and maintaining optimal performance might require continuous adjustments of the measurement setup. Here we present a method for the selection and adjustment of an optimal measurement setup. First, the landscape is measured and analyzed to calculate theory-based accurate OVL values as well as quality metrics which depend on details of the pupil image. These OVL values and metrics are then used as an internal ruler (“self-reference”), effectively eliminating the need for an external reference such as CD-SEM. Finally, an optimal measurement setup is selected by choosing a setup which yields the same OVL values as the self-reference and is also robust to small changes in the landscape. We present measurements which show how a SCOL landscape changes within wafer, wafer to wafer, and lot to lot with intentionally designed process variations between. In this case the process variations cause large shifts in the SCOL landscape and it is not possible to find a common optimal measurement setup for all wafers. To deal with such process variations we adjust the measurement setup as needed. Initially an optimal setup is chosen based on the first wafer. For subsequent wafers the process stability is continuously monitored. Once large process variations are detected the landscape information is used for selecting a new measurement setup, thereby maintaining optimal accuracy and robustness. Methods described in this work are enabled by the ATL (Accurate Tunable Laser) scatterometry-based overlay metrology system.
In recent years, lithographic printability of overlay metrology targets for memory applications has emerged as a significant issue. Lithographic illumination conditions such as extreme dipole, required to achieve the tightest possible pitches in DRAM pose a significant process window challenge to the metrology target design. Furthermore, the design is also required to track scanner aberration induced pattern placement errors of the device structure. Previous workiii, has shown that the above requirements have driven a design optimization methodology which needs to be tailored for every lithographic and integration scheme, in particular self-aligned double and quadruple patterning methods. In this publication we will report on the results of a new target design technique and show some example target structures which, while achieving the requirements specified above, address a further critical design criterion – that of process resilience.
We present a metrology target design (MTD) framework based on co-optimizing lithography and metrology performance. The overlay metrology performance is strongly related to the target design and optimizing the target under different process variations in a high NA optical lithography tool and measurement conditions in a metrology tool becomes critical for sub-20nm nodes. The lithography performance can be quantified by device matching and printability metrics, while accuracy and precision metrics are used to quantify the metrology performance. Based on using these metrics, we demonstrate how the optimized target can improve target printability while maintaining the good metrology performance for rotated dipole illumination used for printing a sub-100nm diagonal feature in a memory active layer. The remaining challenges and the existing tradeoff between metrology and lithography performance are explored with the metrology target designer’s perspective. The proposed target design framework is completely general and can be used to optimize targets for different lithography conditions. The results from our analysis are both physically sensible and in good agreement with experimental results.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.